| 1 - 3 | Chicken of the Sea - Aquatic Cocatrice, poisonous, but spicy white-meat if you kill it. |
| 4 - 6 | -06 Giant Turtle - 60’ to 600' shell. Appears to be false island. Goes under when shipwrecked sailors swim to it. |
| 7 - 9 | Ginormous Turtle - Has mountains and waterfalls on it. Long snaking head can pluck visitors off it for snacks. |
| 10 - 15 | Sum Fish - 1d12 Giant 18' fish. Each fish in the school, increases the size of all others, by +18’ feet in length. |
| 16 | Treasure Whale - Whale filled with doubloons. Notoriously hard to catch, but drawn to fair maidens exposing their assets. Sometimes to feet. |
| 17 - 24 | No Monster Encountered |
| 25 - 28 | Flock of Seagulls - English ships gain +2 Morale, other nationalities -2 |
| 29 - 35 | Angry Cloud - Ship is rained on with otherwise clear skies. |
| 36 - 40 | Albatross - Lucky kill, any sailor who shoots it gets 2d6 Doubloons |
| 41 - 60 | No Monster Encountered |
| 61 - 62 | Pir Ship - Armed Sloop with gigantic library of stollen books, mostly pornography, available for free |
| 63 - 70 | Pirate Ship - Predatory ship that will kill you and take your stuff |
| 71 - 76 | Pirat-e Ship - As above, but the crew is specialized in a martial art that is baffling and effective. "Pira-teh” |
| 77 - 83 | No Monster Encountered |
| 84 | Kraken - Terrifyingly huge octopus like sea hunter. SO. MANY. TENTACLES. |
| 85 - 86 | Karen - Female Kraken, Demands to speak to captain. Wants specific crew fiung off into the sea. |
| 87 - 88 | Sea Serpent - 200' long sea-snake, coils can crush a ship to splinters. Bad news |
| 89 - 90 | Si-Serpent - 80’ Telepathic serpent that can mentally talk Spaniards into doing their worst desires |
| 91 - 94 | Siren - Loud, annoying monster that hangs out on rocky crags. An auditory "light house." Has treasure tho. |
| 95 | Megalodon - Shark with a maw the size a galleon wearing nerd glasses. Answers to "Meg.” Polite if approached properly |
| 96 | Duck of Doom - 120' Duck. Ill tempered. |
| 97 | Maelstrom - An intelligent whirlpool that sucks down entire ships and sometimes, small seafaring nations |
| 98 - 99 | Malestrom - Macho whirlpool given to posturing and misogyny. Flees from a fight. |
| 100 | Sea Monkeys - Aquatic primates that scale the ship and carry off sailors in the night. See "Earl Otis Deep One" |
